top of page

Writing History or Telling a Story Somerled MacIan MacSorley and the Challenge of Gaps

Nov 11
6 min read
There is a particular kind of silence that follows you when you write about the twelfth century. It is not the silence of an empty page, exactly. It is the silence of records that were never made, manuscripts that did not survive, and lives that were remembered long after the people themselves were gone.

That silence becomes very real when writing about Somerled MacIan MacSorley, Lord of the Isles.

He is the sort of figure who seems made for a sweeping historical tale. Islands, kinship, sea power, Gaelic and Norse worlds meeting and clashing, ambition, legend, and death. Yet the moment you try to write him carefully, the ground shifts. What do we actually know? What was added later? Where does history end and storytelling begin?

Wide-angle view of a misty Hebridean shoreline with a lone medieval boat near the rocks
The sea is part of Somerled’s story, but it does not give up its records easily.

The problem with a life built from fragments


Writing about Somerled is not like writing about a modern political leader with letters, portraits, newspaper reports, and official records. The twelfth century gives us much less to work with.

Some sources were written later. Some were shaped by political needs, family pride, monastic viewpoints, or the desire to explain how later powers came to be. Names shift between languages and traditions. Dates can be uncertain. Motives are often guessed from outcomes.

That does not make the subject impossible. It makes it delicate.

With Somerled, even the act of naming carries weight. Gaelic, Norse, Scots, and later clan traditions all leave fingerprints on how he is remembered. The man at the centre of it all becomes both historical person and ancestral symbol. He is not just someone who lived. He is someone later generations needed to mean something.

That is fascinating. It is also a trap.

A writer can easily make him too clear, too soon. Give him tidy motives. Give every event a neat cause. Make every silence feel deliberate. The result may be readable, but it risks pretending we know more than we do.

The three-year gap that refuses to behave


The hardest part, for me, is the three-year gap.

A gap of three years may not sound like much in a modern biography. People change jobs, move house, fall out with relatives, marry, recover, plot, fail, learn, and begin again in less time than that. In medieval politics, three years could change everything.

For a figure like Somerled, a missing stretch of time invites questions.

Where was he? Who was he speaking to? Was he building alliances? Recovering from defeat? Waiting? Watching? Raising ships? Negotiating marriages? Losing support? Gaining it quietly?

A narrative writer looks at that gap and sees possibility.

A historian looks at that gap and sees danger.

Both reactions are honest. That is the tension. The blank space asks to be filled, but the evidence does not give permission to fill it fully.

There are ways to handle it. One can state the known facts, mark the gap, and move on. Clean, safe, and truthful. Yet it may leave readers with no sense of the pressure that must have existed around him.

Or one can present a careful reconstruction, using phrases such as “he may have”, “it is possible”, and “one plausible reading is”. That gives shape without claiming certainty. Still, too many cautious phrases can make the writing feel like it is walking through mud.

The challenge is not simply finding the facts. It is deciding how much imagination can stand beside them without taking over.

Why narrative is so tempting


Narrative has power because people understand lives as stories. We look for sequence. We want to know what changed, who acted, who suffered, who gained, and why it mattered.

For Somerled, narrative can do useful work. It can show the world around him, not just list events. It can help readers feel the distance between island communities, the importance of sea routes, the fragility of alliances, and the sheer difficulty of ruling across water and kin groups.

A narrative approach can also make room for uncertainty in a more human way. Instead of saying, “The record is silent for three years,” it can ask what silence means in a world where power often moved by word of mouth, marriage, hostage, oath, and sword.

That kind of writing can bring the past closer.

But it has risks.

A smooth story can hide weak evidence. It can make guesswork sound like fact. It can turn a complex medieval lord into a modern hero, strategist, rebel, or nation-builder, depending on the writer’s taste. The more beautiful the prose becomes, the easier it is to forget the scaffolding underneath.

Storytelling can illuminate history, but it can also decorate uncertainty until it looks solid.

Close-up of a worn medieval manuscript page beside a quill and a small stone weight
Sparse records force every sentence to carry its share of doubt.

Why factual history matters just as much


A factual history has a different kind of strength. It respects the limits of the evidence. It tells readers where the ground is firm and where it is not.

That matters, especially with figures surrounded by later legend. A careful factual account can separate contemporary evidence from later tradition. It can show why one source may be more reliable than another. It can explain that absence of evidence is not proof of absence, while still refusing to invent.

The drawback is that it may feel thin.

A strictly factual account of a poorly documented life can become a sequence of fragments, with long pauses between them. Readers may learn what can be known, but struggle to care. The person at the centre can disappear behind footnotes and caution.

So the question becomes practical. What is the aim of the piece?

A narrative approach can make Somerled vivid, connect events, and help readers imagine the twelfth-century world.
A factual approach can protect accuracy, show uncertainty clearly, and build trust.
It can blur the line between evidence and invention if the writer is not careful.
It can feel dry or incomplete when the source base is thin.

The best answer may sit somewhere between the two.

A possible middle path


I keep coming back to the idea of an openly signposted narrative.

That would mean writing in a way that reads naturally, but never hides the joins. The story can move forward, but the reader is told when the evidence runs out. The three-year gap is not covered over. It becomes part of the subject.

For example, instead of inventing scenes, the writer might frame the gap like this:

For three years, the record gives us almost nothing. That silence is frustrating, but it is also revealing. Whatever Somerled was doing, later events suggest that he did not vanish from the political world around the western seaboard.

That kind of passage does not pretend to know the unknowable. It still gives the reader a way to think about the missing years.

The same method could apply throughout. Use narrative for context, movement, and atmosphere. Use factual history for claims, dates, and interpretation. When the evidence is uncertain, say so plainly. When later tradition colours the story, name it as tradition.

That honesty can become part of the voice.

What kind of book or article does Somerled need?


This is where I would genuinely welcome thoughts.

Should Somerled’s story be written as a spare, careful history, with every uncertainty kept visible? Should it be shaped as a narrative history, rich with context but disciplined about evidence? Or should the project openly combine both, perhaps even letting the gaps become chapters in their own right?

A few questions keep circling:

  • How much uncertainty can a reader accept before the story loses force?
  • How much narrative can a historian use before the account feels over-shaped?
  • Should the three-year gap be treated as a problem to minimise, or as one of the most revealing parts of the whole subject?
  • Is it better to write “we do not know” often, or to build careful possibilities around what little can be known?

For now, my instinct is to avoid pretending the gaps are not there. Somerled’s life does not need false certainty to be compelling. The silence around him is part of the history.

The task is to write in a way that lets the reader feel both things at once: the pull of a powerful story, and the discipline of not claiming too much.

That balance is difficult, but it may be the only honest way to approach him. If you have thoughts, suggestions, warnings, or examples of writers who handle this well, I would love to hear them. How would you tell Somerled’s story without betraying the history?
If you wish to respond e-mail; scottishgothic.com@gmail.com

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

What’s New With Raymond Walker

May the first 2027 will see the release of "The Dark Kind" . a dark Faerie Tale. The River Tales have been going on for almost twenty years and May next year will see them all concluded in a very dranatic finale.

a completely new novel and an ending to all of the river tales.  It will be hearalded, Proclaimed and advertised as both the publishers and public are awaiting a conclusion to "The dead girl and the wandering tree".  Well this is it.

"Sad Green Eyes" will follow soon after. I hope. and a little while after that "The living room" though that may be twenty twenty eight.

. 

the pale shadow.jpg
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

©2019 by www.raytwalker.com Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page